Legacy vs. modern carbon accounting: Advantages and limitations.
- AI
- Carbon accounting
- Energy

Modern carbon accounting methodologies and technologies in use today are not the same as those used ten years ago. In fact, some legacy methods for calculating and reporting emissions were pretty inaccurate, helping to bring the world to the era of 'global boiling' (not our words, but the United Nations).
Thankfully, the increased awareness of the climate crisis, toughening of regulations, and technology sector involvement have yielded much-needed carbon accounting advancements.
Today, we can calculate carbon emissions for products, services, and their value chains with high accuracy – especially when paired with modern software tools. This data helps us manage and optimise energy use and carbon emission output, which in turn helps us on our mission to keep global warming under 1.5 °C.
So let's compare those legacy and modern carbon accounting methods. If you've yet to adopt the more accurate and impactful modern methods and technologies, it's high time you did.
Legacy carbon accounting methods and their challenges
Although carbon accounting and reporting wasn't widely adopted until the 2010s, it has been standardised since 2001 when the Greenhouse Gas (GHG) Protocol was published. This effectively provided a blueprint for businesses to calculate and report their emissions and continues to be used to date as a guide. Some of the weaker practices enabled by the original standards – spend-based estimation, industry averages for Scope 3 – are increasingly discouraged. More importantly, the GHG Protocol itself is actively being updated to address these limitations. More on that below.
Spend-based accounting
Large and small companies relied on spend-based data for calculating their emissions for the longest time. This approach uses the money spent on a product or service and multiplies it by an emission factor. Put simply, this method relies on financial data. Emission factors used by the companies for this method vary by product or activity and are provided by a government agency or organisation. For spend-based accounting, they're expressed per unit of money – kilograms of CO₂e per euro spent, for example.
The problem with spend-based accounting is that prices fluctuate frequently. Therefore, they're not a reliable means for calculating emissions. While it makes the calculations simpler and quicker (we all love simple maths!), it leaves room for marginal errors that can compound over time and result in inaccurate data. And no one likes inaccurate data.
Estimates and industry averages for Scope 3 reporting
Corporations have used the GHG Protocol since its inception, and since 2011 it has had a dedicated Scope 3 Standard. However, a significant shortcoming in the current standard is that it allows and accepts estimates for Scope 3 emissions.
This approach was taken given the complexity of getting accurate emissions data from all suppliers in the value chain, so to make things easier for companies, the Protocol allows companies to use industry averages to calculate their value chain emissions.
For instance, a construction company that sources cement from abroad can use industry averages for carbon emissions per pound of cement. However, using estimates and averages results in staggering incoherencies and doesn't account for many emissions that its value chain produces.
Down with this sort of thing.
The good news: the GHG Protocol Scope 3 Standard is currently under active revision. The GHG Protocol's Scope 3 Technical Working Group – 65 members from more than 20 countries – published a Phase 1 Progress Update in March 2026. It proposes that companies classify and disclose their Scope 3 emissions by data type, so it's clear how much rests on spend-based estimates. The wider work plan goes further and is weighing whether to limit or phase out the spend-based method altogether. Then, in July 2026, the GHG Protocol and ISO announced they're merging their corporate standards into one. A consolidated draft is due for public consultation in Q2 2027, with the final standard expected in Q4 2028.
Legacy accounting tools
In the early days of carbon accounting adoption, either voluntarily or as a result of regulations, general accounting tools were used for calculating emissions. Here's the snag: most of these tools weren't designed for carbon accounting, so they weren't efficient enough to process the data and provide meaningful insights. Unsurprising, really. Legacy tools may also have been easier to manipulate because the standards and regulations weren't as black and white as today.

Modern carbon accounting solutions and their benefits
Fortunately, carbon accounting has come a long way, with many countries like the UK, Australia, and China publishing research studies on it in recent years. Additionally, technological advancements have enabled better collection and reporting of climate-related data, which only helps the advancement. It's like a carbon accounting effectiveness flywheel. If you will.
Here are a few modern, more effective solutions for carbon accounting.
Activity-based data
Activity-based data doesn't just rely on financial data like spend-based accounting. Instead, it also utilises other, more activity-specific data. For instance, the data may indicate the weight of material used, the distance a vehicle travelled, or units sold. Activity-based data is collected from different sources and may come directly from entities in the value chain. That's why it's more accurate than spend-based data. The more activity data you can collect, the more accurate your carbon accounting. Lovely.
Similar to the spend-based method, the activity-based method also relies on emission factors, which, in turn, are calculated using averages for a particular activity.
E-liability accounting system
Citing the shortcomings of the GHG Protocol in reporting Scope 3 emissions, researchers Robert Kaplan and Karthik Ramanna put forth the E-liability climate accounting approach. Their article, published in Harvard Business Review in November 2021, won the 2021 HBR-McKinsey Award for groundbreaking management thinking. Their approach uses cost accounting and inventory practices to eliminate estimates and get real data.
More importantly, this proposed accounting system eliminates duplication in reporting value chain emissions. Since the article was published, Kaplan and Ramanna have set up a not-for-profit to take the method forward – the E-liability Institute, now operating as the E-ledgers Institute, and pilots have been completed across industries including manufacturing and cement – companies including Heidelberg Materials (cement), Tata Steel, BMW Group, and Hitachi Energy have piloted it. It's not a formal standard yet – but its profile has grown considerably, and it's a more transparent approach to carbon accounting that responsible companies can adopt now.
AI-powered analytical tools
Like, seemingly, everything else, carbon accounting software solutions are getting an artificial intelligence (AI) makeover. With machine learning and big data, companies can get detailed and meaningful insights into their carbon footprint. AI solutions can sift through large volumes of data across companies and their value chains far faster than people can – though they're only as accurate as the data they're given on emissions. Moreover, AI-based analytical tools can help detect bottlenecks in reducing carbon emissions.
But that's not all! AI tools for carbon accounting may also be used to predict potential project emissions. That can be instrumental in reducing potential emissions before the project starts.
The importance of innovation in carbon accounting
It goes without saying that innovation in carbon accounting will help us reach net zero by around 2050 – the point the IPCC says global CO₂ emissions need to reach to keep warming to 1.5°C. A primary reason that many companies fail to make a significant impact, despite having intentions to reduce or offset emissions, is that their carbon accounting and energy data collection are flawed.
To make a substantial impact, you need the correct targets. And to set suitable targets, you need accurate emissions data. And you get accurate emissions data by implementing the best tool for the job, a tool that eliminates guesswork and unreliable data and provides real numbers to take action. A tool like, you guessed it, comundo.
The same question is landing on buildings. An energy performance certificate (EPC) rates a building under standard conditions, which is exactly its job – it tells you how good the building itself is. What it can't tell you is what the building actually used last month. Put the two side by side, the EPC you're required to have and metered consumption straight from the source, and you see both: how good the building is, and where it is right now.

Ryan Stevens
Technical content creator
Ryan is a senior technical content creator, helping tech businesses plan, launch, and run a successful content strategy. After an extensive academic career in engineering, he worked with dozens of tech startups and established brands to reach new clients through proven content creation strategies.